Roof Type Comparison

Metal roofs and asphalt shingles are two of the most popular choices for residential and commercial properties, yet they differ significantly in terms of performance, lifespan, and visual appeal. A metal roof often comes with a considerably longer service life—sometimes lasting decades beyond an asphalt roof—while also offering enhanced resilience in extreme weather conditions. Although the initial investment in metal roofing can be higher, many homeowners find that the long-term savings and peace of mind justify the added cost. For individuals seeking a roof that combines strength, durability, and energy efficiency, metal is rapidly becoming the go-to option.

By contrast, asphalt roofs remain a standard in many regions thanks to their relatively low upfront cost and widespread availability. However, they typically require replacement every 10 to 15 years, and may not stand up as well to severe wind or hail. Asphalt shingles also provide fewer color and design variations compared to metal roofing, limiting the ability to customize the look of a property. While this material can be a practical solution for certain budgets and timelines, homeowners who value longevity and style frequently find that metal roofing offers a superior return on investment.

Metal Roofs Compared To Traditional Roofs

Scroll to the right to compare roof types!
Average Lifetime of the Roof:
The Metal Roofers Warranty:
Non-Prorated Warranty:
Length of Roof Install Process:
Wind Rating
Styles and Colors

Metal Roof

Lifetime
Lifetime
Yes
A few days to a week
180+ mph
Huge Variety

Asphalt Roof

10 - 15 years
15 - 30 years*
No
A few days to a week
60 - 100 mph
Limited Choices

Composite Roof

15 - 30 years
1 - 2 weeks
10 - 20 years
15 - 30 years
1 - 2 weeks
10 - 20 years

3 Key Comparisons Between Metal Roofs and Asphalt Shingles

Metal roofs deliver a longer lifespan and more comprehensive warranties than asphalt shingles.

A properly installed metal roof can last several decades longer than its asphalt counterpart, often accompanied by non-prorated warranties that extend throughout the roof’s entire service life. This exceptional longevity and coverage reduce the need for frequent replacements, ultimately offering greater peace of mind and better long-term value.

Metal roofing withstands high winds and severe weather more effectively than asphalt shingles.

With wind ratings that can exceed 180 miles per hour, metal roofs demonstrate remarkable performance in regions prone to storms or harsh climates. Their interlocking panels and robust fastening methods help minimize damage during severe weather, whereas asphalt shingles typically feature lower wind ratings and may be more susceptible to dislodging or tearing.

Metal roofs offer more style and color variety than asphalt shingles.

Available in countless profiles, finishes, and hues, metal roofing allows for extensive customization that can match or enhance virtually any architectural style. While asphalt shingles are generally limited to a narrower palette, metal roofs make it possible to achieve everything from bold, contemporary looks to traditional, rustic designs—without compromising durability.

Savings Calculator

Metal vs. Shingle Roof Savings Over the Lifetime

Type in the square footage of your roof to see how much you could be saving!
Calculate
Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.

Total Lifetime Savings

$0
Low
$0
High
15-30%
Home Insurance Premium Savings
10-20%
Energy Savings
DISCLAIMER: This is not a guarantee on pricing or savings, but gives general range of savings. The Metal Roofers cannot give an accurate price or savings expectation without first seeing the home due to factors such as roof design, multiple stories, type of metal roofing, and more. Likewise, insurance companies vary in their premium reductions for metal roofs and energy savings depend on numerous variables.
Call Today!
(615) 649-5002
Roof

Don't Settle For Less Than Metal

Schedule Your Free Quote Today!

Schedule Your Free Quote